By John R. Byrne
Want to make sure the Supreme Court never hears one of your legal disputes? Sign them all to book deals. At least, that might be a way to avoid the justices from considering your case.
This past Monday, six justices--Alito, Sotomayor, Gorsuch, Barrett and Jackson--recused themselves from considering the cert petition in a case called Baker v. Coates. The plaintiff (Baker) was an author who sued another author (Coates), claiming that Coates's book, The Water Dancer, plagiarized his book. The trial court dismissed the complaint and the Second Circuit affirmed. And that's where the lawsuit will end. Because of the recusals, the Supreme Court lacked the requisite quorum (the magic number is 6) to consider Baker's cert petition.
Though the justices didn't say why they recused (they aren't required to), the speculation is that it's because a party in the case owns Penguin Random House, which has published (or plans to publish) books by Sotomayor, Gorsuch, Barrett, and Jackson. So, by federal statute--28 U.S.C. § 2109--the Second Circuit becomes the final arbiter of the dispute. Newsweek covers it here.
Unrelated, the Miami New Times just ran this list featuring "22 Old School Miami Restaurants." Some classics on this list. Still haven't tried a hot dog from Arbetter's.